“The media portrays CPS caseworkers as overworked, not caring or knowing how to keep kids safe,” said Evans. “It perpetuates the stigma that keeps families from asking for help.”
Media tends to dramatize and foster negative stereotypes of the child welfare system, including the role of CPS caseworkers.
“I came to the job knowing what families can go through,” said Yesenia Fonseca-Alicea, CPSTT Casework Coach. She is the newest recruit to the Training Team but has six years of experience working with CPS. “TV and movies often get it wrong.”
However, there are real stories that get it right, notably the memoir and documentary Healing Neen, which is used as a training tool to educate new caseworkers on trauma-focused care and in understanding family dynamics.
“The story of Tonier Cain (who overcame a childhood of severe abuse, homelessness and addiction through intervention) is about client resilience,” said Alison Chrysler, CPSTT Senior Caseworker. Chrysler has 14 years of experience working with CPS. “Her ability to turn her life around underscores the need for prevention, especially for those who have experienced generational trauma.”
“People need help, not punitive measures,” offered Katie Alkins, CPSTT Senior Caseworker with eight years of experience working with CPS. “Everyone has a story. Trauma or Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACEs) need to be addressed.”
Alkins referenced The Pitt, a popular medical drama series that premiered on HBO Max last year, as an example of an accurate portrayal of social workers. In Season 2, episodes 2 and 3, a child is brought to the ER with suspicious injuries.
“In these episodes, social workers and doctors, who are mandated reporters, gather information prior to a report being made,” explained Alkins. “It portrays the intervention piece accurately, as cases don’t always rise to the level of abuse or neglect.”
“There is a Ted Talk by Jessica Price, who wrote “Broken,” a book from her time as a child welfare worker,” Evans said. “Her message is one of strengthening families through help and support. Being able to partner with a family and listening to their story without judgment is the first step in any helping relationship.”